Monthly Rentals in Brewers Bay

The Airbnb was clean and tidy and made good use of a small space. However it is listed as a tiny home, I thought it would be a stand alone tiny home and it was not. It is part of a little complex of what felt like tiny rooms more than tiny homes. This would be perfect for one person but felt cramped for two people. What you see is what you get. We stayed at another air bnb on the island and while both were further away from the main shopping and eating areas this one felt EXTRA far away. Just be aware that you will have to drive 30 minutes up and down STEEP hills to get there. Overall a good stay with pretty views and lovely nature sounds all around. Lorna was quick to respond when we were locked out upon arrival and had good local suggestions.

We had a great stay. Incredible view and location, high value for the cost. Hull Bay beach was a 2min drive down the road, super peaceful and quiet. Solid restaurant and bar "The Shack" right on the beach. We were happy to have available to us many of the provided beach amenities - towels, chairs, cooler, snorkeling gear. The roads all over the island are something else, so I'd recommend a 4WD car with high road clearance.

I honestly cannot say enough amazing things about this home and the hosts. The home itself was way better than the pictures and the view was BEAUTIFUL! I was there alone and at no point did I feel unsafe in the neighborhood. The location is pretty quiet and peaceful, which is nice. Super clean home and it had everything I needed and more! The host was so helpful, friendly and responsive from booking to checkout. He even allowed me to check in early and followed up to make sure I was doing alright during my stay. If you’re considering this place, please just book it! You will not be disappointed. 10/10 would stay again & DEFINITELY would recommend. Literally nothing bad to say!

This was our second time staying at Sheila’s, and it was just as incredible as the first! The space is cozy and thoughtfully designed, with every detail taken care of. Sheila is a fantastic host—warm, attentive, and quick to respond. We can’t wait to come back for a third stay. Highly recommend!!