Monthly Rentals in Smithtown Bay

Gaby’s place was clean and comfortable! She is very kind and it was exactly what we needed for the week. Her check in instructions and directions were thorough and the home is in a beautiful area. Already have our next stay booked :)

Our stay at Zee’s place was great! He was so accommodating, even purchased a brand new pack and play for our infant. The place was spotless, and very comfortable. We will definitely be staying again!

I booked this cottage for my family quickly and only a day or two in advance, barely looking at the listing beyond location and sleeping arrangements. When we arrived, we were all pleasantly surprised at how comfortable and lovely this little home was. I have never encountered such a thoughtfully designed rental. I was recovering from a surgery, had two weary young children, and we were in town for an unexpected funeral. From the games to the beds to the toiletries, every aspect of this cottage soothes and welcomes. Our stay made a difficult time a little easier, and I am very appreciative to Lise for creating such a hospitable and lovely cottage and sharing it with others.

The place was exactly like the photos, and the host was incredibly kind and responsive. When I caught a cold, they were so thoughtful and even brought me some medicine. I also loved hearing the occasional baby sounds—it made me happy. I truly wish the host and their family all the best! The train station is about a 35-minute walk or a $10 Uber ride away. There’s a bus to the station, but the nearest bus stop is a 20-minute walk. The closest Starbucks is also about a 20-minute walk, but I actually enjoyed walking there often. The neighborhood is very quiet and friendly.