Vacation rentals in Setauket Harbor

Find and book unique accommodations on Airbnb

Top-rated vacation rentals in Setauket Harbor

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness, and more.

0 of 0 items showing

1 of 3 pages

Superhost

Home in Milford

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 26 reviews

Light-filled Beach House Steps from the Sand

Located in prime Bayview Beach, a one min stroll to the sandiest beach in Milford. Two floors with private patio. Main level: half-bath, Cooks kitchen with a 6 person dining area, living room with flatscreen. Upstairs: master w/king size bed & en-suite bath, kids bedroom w/ bunkbed, another full bath w/ tub. 3rd bedroom with queen bed and trundle twin. If you want a get-a-way from the city, or just an escape then come to this tucked-away home. Enjoy all that this coastline gem has to offer.

Guest favorite

Home in Bayport

4.83 out of 5 average rating, 162 reviews

Exquisite spacious waterfront all modern-sleeps 8

READ THE CONSISTENT FINE REVIEWS! Its heart-warming providing such a nice sanctuary! This MEMORABLE Sayville / Bayport Vacation rental home has a picturesque backyard & amazing water views. 3Br 2 full bath. Enjoy the 2-person steam shower & huge 10-person whirlpool bath for spa-like living. Perfect for quiet getaways. All new furniture w/ coastal chic decor. Feed 6 ducks, 2 swans, 2 cranes. The serenity & one-of-a kind view sets this Sayville vacation home apart from all others.

Guest favorite

Home in Northport

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Cool pad, Private Rms, Walk to village, Wtr view

Beautiful pad on a tranquil street and walkable neighborhood. 5-10 minute walk to the village and 2-minute walk to the cliffs overlooking the bay and sound. Water view from one bedroom, great outdoor yard - very private. Updated amenities, marble bathroom, cozy indoor living area and very comfortable beds. The rental space is private and is the entire first floor of the home. The home is a two-story duplex with a shared entrance and private locking doors to each space. Wonderful location.

Superhost

Home in Baldwin

4.85 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Clarissa's Paradise

RESERVE NOW: This ideally located five-bedroom totally renovated home is the perfect spot for a family fun vacation. Located within walking distance of the well known playground and spray ground. The home features a spacious patio, central air conditioning, baseboard heating, WiFi, and Cable tv. The open layout provides perfect gathering spaces for your family, and all bedrooms are spacious and comfortably appointed. 4 full bathrooms . Sleeps 10. PLEASE NO PARTIES ARE STRICKLY PROHIBITED

Superhost

Vacation home in Elmont

4.82 out of 5 average rating, 82 reviews

Lovely 2-Bedroom Elmont Apartment (Lower Level)

Enjoy this centrally-located lovely full 2-bedroom private lower level apartment. With 2 Queen sized beds, this space can host up to 4 people comfortably. Ideal for travelers or families visiting NY. Located in a quiet neighborhood. In the center of many shops, restaurants, highways. This apartment is located 7 minutes away from the USB Arena, 10-15 minutes away from JFK airport, and in close proximity to Roosevelt Field Mall and Green Acres Mall. The next adventure is never too far away!

Guest favorite

Home in Bellport

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 37 reviews

Gorgeous Bellport Village Getaway with Heated Pool

A very special and warm vacation home in historic Bellport Village with 3-4 spacious bedrooms, well-appointed living spaces, beautifully-maintained garden and grounds and a wonderful heated saltwater pool. Great for weddings and other life events. Minutes from village, marina and playground at the water's edge. Perfect for a family getaway from the city. Perfect for people who love to cook. We promise you a clean, lovely home with all of the comforts for a pleasurable stay.

Superhost

Home in Westhampton Beach

5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Summer Main Home plus cottage close to Main Street

Come relax and enjoy! Beautifully updated Main home with separate cottage. Perfect for in-laws and guests. Each home has its own kitchen, living space, washer/dryer, and outdoor seating. Main house: 4 Br, 3 ba Cottage: 2 Br, 1 ba Outdoor shower for an after beach rinse, 2 patios, pergola, hammock, bbq. A two person kayak available for use; beach passes included. Games, internet, tv... Walk to coffee shops, restaurants, worship, and marina. Bike to beach.

Guest favorite

Houseboat in Riverhead

5 out of 5 average rating, 10 reviews

Peconic River Boatel

Perfectly updated nautical houseboat situated on the scenic Peconic River. Featuring two picturesque bedrooms, a full service eat-in kitchen and a living room with panoramic river view. Enjoy your morning coffee on the outside deck while taking in the sunrise. This historic waterfront town was named to Forbes Advisor’s “Best Places to Travel in 2023” — one of just 11 U.S. destinations on this year’s list. A must see for adventurers and families alike!

Guest favorite

Home in Remsenburg-Speonk

5 out of 5 average rating, 39 reviews

5-Star Listing: Hamptons Oasis, Easy from NYC

Welcome to our coastal retreat. Minutes away from Westhampton Beach and a super-easy commute from NYC. Perfect for families or a group of close friends to get away from it all. A bright, spacious, recently renovated home with light-filled rooms, new floors, coastal decor. Ultrafast Wifi, Alexas, and a new kitchen with the latest appliances. Beautifully landscaped gardens, heated pool, 6-person salt water hot tub (in winter or summer)!

Guest favorite

Home in Milford

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

Modern Beach Getaway

This 4 bedroom, 3 bathroom vacation rental in Milford, CT, boasts beautiful hardwood floors, high ceilings, and an open-concept living area perfect for entertaining guests. Each bedroom is tastefully decorated, and the fenced-in private yard features a deck and firepit area. The rental is located across the street from a private beach and is a short drive from local shops and restaurants, making it the ideal spot for a summer getaway.

Guest favorite

Home in Mastic

4.88 out of 5 average rating, 98 reviews

Cozy home. Comfy living

The whole group will enjoy easy access to everything from this centrally located home. three comfortable bedroom and two bathrooms with a large living room, dining and kitchen. close to the beach, nature reserved, kayaking, sky diving and Tanger outlet mall, restaurant and all the fast food located nearby. long island vast array of winery and farms stand etc.

Superhost

Guesthouse in Hampton Bays

5 out of 5 average rating, 21 reviews

2 Bedroom Hamptons Waterfront Cottage Rental

This incredible 2 Bedroom, 1 Bath 750 sq ft Cottage is steps from an inlet leading out to Peconic Bay. The cottage sleeps 4 adults comfortably. Bedroom 1 currently has 2 Twins, Bedroom 2 has a queen Bed, but 2 twins can be requested. The cottage has a private entrance and private deck with BBQ, kitchen, and living area.