Cottage vacation rentals in Presque Isle

As other reviewers have said, Cynthia has a great little get-away. We changed arrival plans/departure plans and she was very accomdating to each request. Really enjoyed the cats, they are very friendly. Beware, the stairs to the upstairs living area are bit tricky to navigate, especially when carrying a bag.

Staying at Sally’s rentals has become a family tradition for us. She is an excellent host who has provided us with kindness, flexibility, and extremely quick responses when anything has come up. Her properties are well-stocked, offering the comforts of home and so much more. We come back every year because we’ve had such positive experiences. It truly feels like a home away from home for us!

My husband and I really enjoyed staying at Kathleen’s place. As soon as we walked in we felt right at home. Beautiful, clean home. We loved the kitchen. The kitchen is well stocked. We liked the little coffee bar area that was set up. Also loved the little nook in the master bedroom to do my hair and makeup. The jacuzzi was very clean and great to use. The home is tucked away in the woods, private and peaceful. Very reliable Wi-Fi. Comfortable bed, we slept well every night. Kathleen was a wonderful host. Answered any questions quickly and checked on us to be sure everything was going ok during our stay.

My family and I stayed at Tony’s place for a long weekend and I have to say it was amazing!! First of all Tony made sure that we had proper directions to the property and how to access the house. Upon entering the house we were astounded by how lovely Tony’s lake house is and then the views of the lake were just panoramic!! We could not have found for a better place to stay! We had easy access to our own private little beach, it was literally right outside the sliding glass doors and we could sit on the patio and watch the sun both rise and set. The kitchen was fully equipped, the house was very spacious and we were excited to find a bookshelf full of childrens books which made our little one very happy. Yes there were quite a few steps to access the property but we found the journey up and down the steps very doable and the path was very well lit. It was exciting going down those steps through the wooded property and watching the lake views unfold. We would definitely return!!

Very comfortable. It shows that you get breakfast but I think that is for the bed and breakfast price. Our price was excellent for what we received.

The house was beautiful and very clean. it was a very short distance to the beach and great restaurants which is what we were looking for.

The home was beautiful, very comfortable and my family felt right at home. Very walkable neighborhood and it was great for walking the dogs. Private fenced in back yard with two decks. Great selection of board games for us to play. Washer and dryer. The owner communicate ahead of time, made us aware of how to access the home and the guest book. Super great to have! Restaurant locations and things to do. Very responsive with questions about boat, kayak and wave runner rentals. Couldn’t have been happier with our stay.

We had a great time at the Lodge. Big beautiful plot of land the lodge sits on. The fire pit and pre cut wood made the evenings outside very enjoyable. We will be back!

Grew up in the area and came back to visit family. Stayed here for a quiet weekend break and this place was clean, comfortable and had all the amentities. It was quiet and easy to unwind. I highly reccomend this gem.

This was our fourth stay at Jeff and Anne’s beautiful lake home and it just gets better every year. So peaceful and the surroundings are just spectacular. Jeff was quick to respond to our questions and made sure we had everything we needed for another wonderful vacation.

We had a wonderful stay at the cottage! It was exactly as expected—clean, comfortable, and located on a quiet street. Perfect for both kids and dogs. We appreciated the games, Keurig, and the convenience of the washer and dryer. Everything was spotless and ready for us to use. Highly recommend!

Summer Haven is exactly as advertised. It's a beautiful home, right on the water, with the best views on the Lake. The owners were very welcoming and kind. Their cottage is next to their home and they have put a ton of love and time into their property. It was quiet, serene, and relaxing. The location is close to the Institute, restaurants, and shops. Mayville is by far the best spot on the lake. It's a short drive to Bemus Point and Jamestown. The home was comfortable and provided lots of towels, bedding, and comfort. I gave the cost 4 stars as it's so expensive to rent any property today. If the cost remains the same next year, we'd LOVE to return! Also, thank you for allowing our pets to come with us. They are family and it wouldn't be a vacation without them. Truly appreciate the inclusion of furry pets. Thanks!

Ray and Patty were accessible even though we had no issues or need to contact them. The little treats and breakfast items were a nice touch. We would stay there again.

Exceeded our expectations. Perfect get away for us and our dog.

Home was clean and cozy and the fire pit was a great spot to relax at the end of the day :)

Matt’s place was perfect for my family and I we enjoyed the privacy while being close to everything we were there to do! Very responsive and made us feel at home will definitely stay again in the future.

Wonderful place right on the water. Wish we stayed longer to enjoy the fire table and deck.

The Sunrise Inn provided a cozy and comfortable stay where great memories were made. Due to the weather, we unfortunately did not get to make a bonfire or enjoy the beautiful front porch with views of the lake, but we did see a rainbow over the lake! The kitchen and bathroom were spotless, and the kitchen was well equipped for cooking / entertaining. We made breakfast at the cottage and enjoyed eating at the local restaurants (The Anchor, Frog Pond, and Happi Jax). Valerie was a very friendly and responsive host, and we would definitely recommend her place to future guests visiting the lake!

Kurt has a cute house! He was also very responsive. Would recommend!

We had a great stay at Rebecca and Eric's cottage. The layout of the home is great, and it provided more than enough space for four adults and one child. We loved our morning walks to the lake and through the neighborhood - such a peaceful and relaxing setting. Check-in and check-out were seamless, and Rebecca and Eric were very quick to respond to any questions we had. We would love to stay again the next time we are in town!

Amy’s place was a great stay for us. It was my husband, 4y/o, and 9 month old. 3 bedrooms. Two by the front bathroom with stand shower and a master with its own bathroom and shower/tub. Master bed big enough for all of us comfortably. Kitchen had everything we needed including a coffee maker and glass blender. They have kitchen towels, bath towels, and rags. Fully stocked with TP. They had a full roll of paper towels and two trash bags in kitchen can. Bathrooms were clean with good working showers. Dining table was great for our meals and playing board games (some available at the cottage). Couch was a good size that we could all be comfortable for movies. Their TV had lots of channels and has options for the streaming service logins. The internet was good. No dishwasher or washer/dryer (as mentioned) which for me was quite pleasant and gave it a more simple feel. Walk to lake was nice with our beach cart and stroller. 10/10 recommend. Amy was so nice and helpful with any questions.

It was a great house. Plenty of room and everything you need. Great location and close to the lake. Beds were very comfortable. Lots of things to keep your kids occupied, if you have them here. We were very pleased with our stay.