Vacation rentals with a fireplace in Northwest Harbor

This house is in a quiet safe neighborhood, 30 mins from Montauk Beach and half the cost for 5 guests. Overall we loved it! The host recommended restaurants which is helpful. When we-reported a problem, someone was there to fix it the next morning. Kitchen well stocked, plenty of outdoor seating, comfy couches. Strange full bathroom cotton curtains a bit long and no liner, difficult to dry. The bath off the master bedroom the floor floods because curtain in there is lined but a bit short. Gotta keep a towel down. Garage is wonderful, laundry in basement handy. Decks off bedroom and patio off dining room both lovely. are beautiful lovely place to stay.

Aida was a great host! She was a great communicator.

The house was very cozy, incredibly clean. View of the river was fantastic. Ned and Sharyn also had helpful notes and labels throughout the house, which I thought was quite kind and helpful!

The moment we stepped into the house our holidays began: it got everything we needed and had such welcoming vibe. Clean, charming and cosy. And not to forget the great quiet location, just a couple of minutes away from the restaurants of Sag Harbor, the shops in East Hampton and the fantastic beaches. The host is highly responsive and solved a - minor - issue within hours. We can highly recommend this place!!

Ashley’s place was absolutely incredible for our girls weekend in Montauk. Impeccably clean, spacious, and tastefully furnished. The hot tub was perfect after a winter hike, and the firepit was great for s’mores and stargazing at night. There was also an indoor fireplace in the living room where we had a couple of really fun movie nights. The kitchen is a dream, and very well equipped with everything you would ever need to cook a fabulous meal. The spacious open plan kitchen/dining area/living room was perfect for communal cooking and hanging out. Gets great light and such a pretty view. The bedrooms were super comfortable and the master has an amazing tub. The location was perfect. Right in town and a short walk to the beach (also walking distance to the brewery!), but also felt very private. Lastly, Ashley was an excellent host- very communicative and helpful and super sweet- she even left a treat for us in the fridge when we arrived! Will definitely be coming back to stay at

My family and I stayed at the Boulder Lake House Retreat during the holiday season. It served as a great home base to spend time with family and was a short drive to downtown Madison, CT and Hammonasset State Park. The space was perfect for our family, in great shape and beautifully decorated. The view from the kitchen was beautiful; even in winter we enjoyed looking out over the frozen lake. All rooms were updated and had great amenities, including rainfall shower heads and foam mattresses. Jhismery was a great host and was very responsive! Hope to be back in the future!

Terrific stay at Ellen’s lovely cottage. The house is warmly decorated and cozy. Amazing patio with outdoor fireplace and big gas grill. Fully equipped kitchen for gourmet cooking. The bathrooms are new and very clean. Lots of delightful and thoughtful little touches. A great base for exploring the North Fork!

What a lovely place! Kitchen was a pleasure to use. Location was great for wineries and Greenport restaurants/bars. Spacious.

If I really liked it instead

We loved staying at Nick’s while in Southampton! The property is quiet and private, with a short walk to the bay. The inside was clean and well furnished. We loved that it was pet friendly- there was a $50 pet fee which we didn’t know about when booking but we were happy to pay given how great the property was. We’d happily stay again!

Paris is a wonderful host. His property and cottage is a perfect retreat for two. Charming accommodations with a beautiful view and an easy walk to town. We’ll be back soon! Angelo C.

This was my second stay in less than two months at Wilson’s place. My family and I enjoy the ability to park our rental, separate TV watching spaces for each bedroom, and separate sleeping areas. The house is now my home away from home after staying at several others since bringing my daughter to college here; but Wilson & Co-host Jaime are amazing! Always super responsive not automated messages, very clean and comfortable living space, and well Stocked with key essentials and good location off 95 making it easy to go to Little Italy, Yale shops and well known tourist sites and restaurants. Corner house off busy street but at night you hear nothing. Great window coverings and having 2 full baths are essential. I highly recommend this space and the great hosts. This is my new home away from home after a second successful trip!

Joanne’s place is a great cozy and spacious one bedroom apartment that my husband and I enjoyed relaxing at. We found it so comfortable we decided to stay an extra night since we are off from work this week and wanted to just chill out there a bit longer. Joanne was always responsive and easily accepted the reservation change to stay an extra day which was nice of her. I would definitely recommend her place and stay again in the future.

The studio was really nice and peaceful and the host is very responsive literally at anytime. Cool nice lil spot. Definitely will book again.

Lovely, clean, comfortable, well-designed space. Hosts are friendly, responsive, and respectful of guests’ privacy. Would stay again!

Immaculate, tasteful home right in Montauk. Lots of thoughtful details and Scandi design that was just our taste. Particularly enjoyed (the pre-laid) wood stove that kept us toasty on a very cold and windy week in February.

Can’t say enough great things about this place and Ann Marie!! She was very responsive, helpful and accommodating every step of the way. The house was extremely clean and comfortable. The fireplace added that extra touch of coziness and we enjoyed cooking in the beautiful kitchen! Anyone looking for a place in East Hampton should definitely check this one out!!

We had a great stay at George’s house. He was very responsive to our questions. Our kids loved the heated outdoor pool! They also loved that there was a playground right across the street from the house. We had a great time!

Aimee’s house on Shelter Island was the perfect getaway for Thanksgiving. The home is warm, inviting, and beautifully maintained, with thoughtful touches that made our stay extra special. The location is serene and peaceful, offering a true escape from the hustle and bustle. Aimee was a fantastic host—responsive, friendly, and helpful throughout. We truly enjoyed our time here and wouldn’t hesitate to return!

Lydia was an excellent host. She communicated all information clearly and kindly. The house was very clean and as described in the ad. We 100% recommend staying here and will definitely be back ourselves. 💯

Wow, this has been one of the most beautiful homes I have stayed at. Straight out of Architectural Digest indeed - Jenna has a true eye for outstanding decor! Jenna is a host to dream of! Thank you we had a beautiful weekend!

We love love loved our stay here.

Harry’s place was what we needed, perfect for a family of 4 (or 5). Its cozy and has what you need for a few days escape from the city. I particularly like how responsive Harry was, even things outside of their control (weather, storm) he looked for immediate solutions. You can see that they care about their place and renters. The pool was a plus for our kids. The location is also good, of course you need a car but there are nice restaurants within 10 min drive and the beach is close too. All in all a very positive experience for us. Thanks Harry!

It was perfect for the holidays it made everything better for me and my family