Vacation rentals in Diamond Island

Thank you! We had a wonderful time and hope to be back. The gourmet dog treat was a fantastic surprise and a nice touch!

Our stay at Tony and Leah’s cottagecore escape was nothing short of magical! From the moment we arrived, we were greeted with warmth and hospitality—the perfect hosts who have clearly poured love and care into creating this serene lakeside haven. The space itself is even more beautiful in person. The stunning lake views from nearly every room, the luxurious soaking tub, and the cozy screened porch (a lifesaver for bug-free relaxation!) made it impossible not to unwind. The kitchen was fully equipped with brand-new appliances, making cooking meals a joy, and the king-sized bed was so comfortable, we woke up feeling refreshed every morning. Our favorite spot? The dreamy daybed by the sliding glass doors—perfect for reading with a view—and the deck, where we enjoyed coffee at sunrise and grilled dinners at sunset. The no-wake lake made for peaceful kayaking, and the dock was ideal for lazy afternoons by the water.

The house was great.  We were a group of 10 and still had a bedroom leftover.  The living room was perfect for the kids to play and watch movies.  We used the grill in the front of the house most nights-It's a cool spot to cook and relax- we even saw the deer across the street.  We spent most of our time at the beach.  The golf cart regardless of the beach we picked is a must.  The sticker on the cart allows you to park at the beach for free.  We were pleasantly surprised by how close of a walk  we were to Old Harbor Village.  Downtown and the beach were about 5 minute walk.  Cannot wait for next summer!

Kate thought of everything and was a wonderful host! The hot tub and sauna were amazing and really helped us relax this weekend.

I will call it "Mary Poppins", practically perfect in every way. If you are looking for a quite scenic vacation spot, this is it. Their are obviously things that could have been better, but we got exactly what we wanted, no notes, no issues, no problems.

Amazing! Charlotte's property is beautiful and welcoming. Perfect amount of space for our getaway weekend with an easy walk to the beach and access to nearby restaurants, shops, etc. Kitchen and baths are fully equipped and stocked with everything you could possibly need and the beds are all very comfortable. Outside seating around the firepit and hot tub is plentiful. Charlotte is a wonderful host. Very responsive, very proactive, and provided tons of recommendations for the area. We loved it and can't wait to plan another stay!

This was an amazing condo! Beautifully decorated and so clean with comfy furniture and beds. Had super clean bathroom with nice water pressure in the shower. Walkable to everything! Best location and Rarick was a great host !! Super helpful. Would give this place 10 stars if I could. Don’t hesitate to rent this place !! Loved our time in South Haven !!

Lovely updated home perfect for our family of 3. We had every thing we needed as well as incredible views of the sunrise and a 5 minute walk to the beach to view the sunset. Neighborhood is also very nice and quiet. Host was top notch, David was very responsive and provided excellent recommendations. Only criticism would be the cleanliness could have been better but David did reply quickly regarding our concerns to address it.

I brought my four kids age 2-16 for some special time at the lake, dunes, and St Joseph. We really enjoyed the home, it was very comfortable, clean and tastefully decorated… comfy beds, well stocked but not cluttered kitchen, and my little ones absolutely loved the children’s bedroom. The private beach is an easy walk and it’s beautiful. Kristi had great recommendations and is the most gracious and hospitable host.